Our Story

About Us

About Us
With a 45-year history as an Italian food chef in both New York and New Jersey restaurants, Stefano Sr. opened his own pizzeria 25 years ago in Pompton Plains. Located on Bustling Route 23 South, it's easy to drive right by this popular eatery set back off the roadway, but once found, Stefano’s is a great place for a quick bite for lunch or a relaxing dinner in its formal dining room.

Nine years ago, the Stefano family expanded their restaurant and opened the intimate dining room. The Tuscan décor and opera music create a romantic ambiance for dinner. Tables are also provided outside for al fresco dining. “We are always happy to greet our regular clientele and also enjoy watching new customers walk in the door, "says Stefano Sr. “We know that once they taste our fresh homemade pasta, they will come back again.”